Integration of Education
ISSN (print): 1991-9468, ISSN (online): 2308-1058
Founder and publisher: National Research Ogarev Mordovia State University
Editor-in-Chief: Dmitriy E. Glushko, Cand.Sci. (Ped.)
Frequency / Access: 4 issues per year / Open
Included in: White list (1st level), Higher Attestation Commission List, RISC, RSCI, Scopus
Website: https://edumag.mrsu.ru
Integration of Education – a peer-reviewed open-access scholarly journal. The journal Integration of Education publishes original scientific articles (Full Articles) in Russian and English, previously not published in other editions. The aim of the journal is an objective presentation of results of original scientific research of current leading tendencies of educational processes, analysis of pedagogical, psychological and sociological problems of education development in Russia and the international scientific community.
The journal’s mission is to maintain and develop a unified research space in the field of education integration, as well as to foster interuniversity cooperation of academic staff.
The journal is addressed to researchers, analysts and practitioners in the field of pedagogy, psychology and sociology of education, as well as to a wide range of readers interested in the problems of integrating education in modern society.
The Editorial Board reviews (double-blind review) all incoming papers. The manuscript of the article is sent for review to several leading specialists of the corresponding profile, who have scientific specialization closest to the subject of the article, to evaluate the scientific content.
The Editorial Board follows the principle of zero tolerance to plagiarism. Plagiarism сhecking is carried out by using Anti-Plagiarism and iThenticate software.
The journal adheres to editorial ethics standards following international practice of editing, reviewing, publishing and authorship of scientific publications and recommendations of the Committee on Publication Ethics (COPE).
The journal is distributed in Russia and other countries of the world.
The journal offers direct open access to full-text issues based on the following principle: open access to research results contributes to the increase of global knowledge sharing.
The Journal is included in the List of peer reviewed scientific journals published by the Higher Attestation Commission in which major research results from the dissertations of Candidates of Sciences (Cand.Sci.) and Doctor of Science (Dr.Sci.) degrees are to be published. Scientific specialties of dissertations and their respective branches of science are as follows:
- Pedagogical psychology, psychodiagnostics of digital educational environments (psychological sciences),
- Social structure, social institutions and processes (sociological sciences),
- Sociology of culture (sociological sciences),
- Sociology of management (sociological sciences),
- General pedagogy, history of pedagogy and education (pedagogical sciences),
- Theory and methods of training and education (by fields and levels of education) (pedagogical sciences),
- Correctional pedagogy (surdopedagogy and typopedagogy, oligophrenopedagogy and speech therapy) (pedagogical sciences),
- Methodology and technology of professional education (pedagogical sciences).
Ағымдағы шығарылым
Том 29, № 3 (2025)
- Жылы: 2025
- ##issue.datePublished##: 22.09.2025
- Мақалалар: 10
- URL: https://bakhtiniada.ru/1991-9468/issue/view/18267
Бүкіл шығарылым
Modernization of Education
Infrastructure Environment of Project-Based Learning in Russian Universities: Experts’ View
Аннотация
Introduction. The introduction of project-based learning in Russian universities is characterised by heterogeneity associated with different starting opportunities and strategies of its implementation. There is a lack of research on the infrastructure of project-based learning, which prevents us from analysing its effectiveness. The aim of the article is to analyse expert assessments of the infrastructural environment of project-based learning in russian higher education institutions, empirical typology of higher education institutions based on its three components: normative, organisational and informational; to identify the relationship between the features of the infrastructural environment and strategic directions of higher education institution policy in the field of project-based learning.
Materials and Methods. The research methodology is based on the application of the environmental approach. The empirical data were collected from March to April 2024 through the implementation of semi-formalised expert interviews, targeting a specific sample. A total of 65 experts were interviewed, including administrators and organisers of project-based learning from 49 regional Russian universities located in 32 cities across all federal districts of the Russian Federation. The hierarchical clustering algorithm using the intra-group links method was used to group universities according to 13 indicators characterizing the project-based learning infrastructure.
Results. The obtained results allowed us to determine the features of the infrastructure environment of Russian universities. An insufficient level of development of the information infrastructure and limited support for project-based learning at the level of individual institutes and faculties were noted. Three clusters of universities and, accordingly, three models of the infrastructure environment of project-based learning were identified: a model of comprehensive integration of project-based learning into the educational environment of the university, a model of active development of the infrastructure of project-based learning, and a model with developing potential for project-based learning. The study’s findings suggest a direct correlation between the sophistication of infrastructure and the scale of implementation of project-based learning. It is posited that as infrastructure evolves, the scope for implementing a mass approach to project-based learning at universities increases.
Discussion and Conclusion. The presented typology of universities by the formation of the infrastructure environment is of great importance for generalizing and comparative analysis of the results of project activities. The results and conclusions of the work are useful not only for researchers, but also for managers seeking to develop project-based learning in their universities.



Integrating Skills and Education to Boost Individual Productivity
Аннотация
Introduction. Despite access to modern technologies, the issue of labor productivity in the Russian Federation remains unresolved to its full extent. Consequently, identifying skill sets as outcomes of scientific and pedagogical activities, for which training is prioritized to increase the productivity of existing and newly created jobs, becomes increasingly relevant. The aim of this research is to identify a set of skills, the development of which impacts individual productive labor activity, as well as to identify high-performance managerial practices in the workplace that enable a significant improvement in an employee’s individual productivity.
Materials and Methods. The article is founded on foreign and domestic data from theoretical and empirical studies of skills for productivity increasing.
Results. The authors have identified four areas of the most relevant skills for increasing individual productivity: skills for a high-tech workplace; skills in managing socio-emotional and psychological condition; skills in managing of social environment for creating of a high-performance work system; entrepreneurial skills (agency) for the formation of a new field of strategic action.
Discussion and Conclusion. Skills’ development should include the training of all skills’ groups: cognitive, hard, soft, “green”, entrepreneurial. Special attention should be paid to the productive socio-emotional condition regulation, that depends both on the internal individual causes and on the creators’ skills of the of the social fields of strategic action.



Monitoring of Education
A Digitized Concept for Tracking Schoolchildren Personal Achievements
Аннотация
Introduction. The need to create a digital portfolio of schoolchildren achievements is emphasized by parents, school administrators, and representatives of relevant federal agencies. Civil society is capable of offering government authorities various options for digitizing the record of schoolchildren personal achievements, which will accelerate the implementation of the ministry’s plans and increase the system’s conformity to the real needs of the population. The research aim is to develop a conceptual framework for an information system that records personal achievements, based on a comprehensive analysis of the needs of modern society.
Materials and Methods. The research was conducted based on information obtained through purposeful searching and extraction of relevant documents from heterogeneous sources of information. For further processing, text document analysis methods were applied: expert text evaluation, intent analysis, and content analysis. Identification of significant factors was carried out using factor analysis with empirical indicators and descriptive statistics. The results’ were generated using statistical methods of comparing means and statistical visualization.
Results. The list of stakeholders of the system was defined, which included schoolchildren, their parents, employees of educational institutions, state educational structures, universities, secondary vocational schools, as well as organizers of thematic contests and Olympiads. The analysis of students’ achievements was conducted, based on which a set of data relevant for storage in the system was selected. A conclusion was made about the general decrease in the number of achievements with the increase in the age of students. A list of functional requirements for the information system for recording personal achievements of schoolchildren was formed. A concept for creating a full-fledged and fully functional information system, a version of the “digital portfolio of a student” that meets the requirements of all stakeholders, was developed.
Discussion and Conclusion. The proposed information system for recording personal achievements of schoolchildren will enable to shape a student’s educational trajectory, automate the reporting system of general education schools on extracurricular achievements, and also assist universities and secondary vocational educational institutions in career guidance for potential applicants. The practical significance of the article lies in the development of recommendations for creating a system to record the achievements of schoolchildren, including its modules and implementation, which is helpful for teachers and civil servants.



Sustainable Development of Higher Education before and after the COVID-19 Pandemic: A Bibliographic Review Study
Аннотация
Introduction. The escalation of environmental concerns has accelerated the discourse on sustainability in higher education. Since 2000, research output has expanded significantly, with the COVID-19 pandemic serving as a stress test for universities’ capacities in financial stability, student enrolment, research continuity, and leadership. The aim of this study is to explore how the discourse on sustainable development in higher education evolved before and after the COVID-19 pandemic and to assess the institutional transformations triggered by the crisis.
Materials and Methods. This study employs a bibliographic review and bibliometric analysis of publications indexed in the Web of Science database. The analysis utilizes VOSViewer software and Google Trends to map research trends, keyword co-occurrence, and thematic clusters.
Results. The findings reveal a marked increase in academic production, thematic diversification, and the growing importance of digital transformation and quality education during crises. Clustered visualizations highlight prominent themes such as the UN Sustainable Development Goals (SDGs), online and hybrid learning, and institutional resilience.
Discussion and Conclusion. This paper contributes to the understanding of how higher education institutions responded to unprecedented challenges and adapted their sustainability strategies in the face of systemic disruption. It offers practical insights for policymakers, academic leaders, and researchers shaping the future of sustainable higher education.



Point of View
“What Can Be Bought Must Be Bought...”: Academic Ethics in the Context of “Normal Anomie” of the Russian Society
Аннотация
Introduction. Despite the impossibility of overestimating the importance of compliance with academic norms in conducting scientific research, there has been an increase in the diversity and number of academic deviations, and violations of academic ethics have become routine and are not perceived by the university community as a serious problem. The attitude of scientists toward violations of academic ethics and the need to comply with them remains insufficiently studied. The purpose of the study is to determine the importance of compliance with academic ethics standards for researchers at universities in the Northwestern Federal District.
Materials and Methods. The study employed a mixed-methods design, combining qualitative and quantitative approaches. Data were collected through five focus groups with postgraduate students from Saint Petersburg universities and an expert online survey of 115 university representatives from the Northwestern Federal District of Russia. Focus groups were organized to familiarize participants with the arguments of young researchers regarding the possibilities of academic deviations. An online survey allowed for quantitative assessments of various positions on the research topic, and the use of scales allowed for a quantitative assessment of qualitative characteristics, in particular the relevance of the problem of academic fraud for universities.
Results. The research hypothesis about the presence of high tolerance for violations of academic ethical norms and a decline in trust in the mechanisms for controlling compliance with these norms was confirmed. Postgraduate students adapt to academic anomie, believing that the requirements of academic ethics in writing dissertations in the humanities and social sciences are very difficult to fulfill. Representatives of educational institutions in the Northwestern Federal District of Russia are willing to justify deviations from academic ethical norms in the presence of objective circumstances. External social control over compliance with academic ethics is recognized as ineffective, due to the impunity of scientists with confirmed plagiarism.
Discussion and Conclusion. The results of the conducted research confirm the dominance of rational and pragmatic expediency in the scientific and pedagogical community today. The norms of academic ethics are declared, but not respected, deviant practices become routine, thereby normalized. According to the respondents, external social control over compliance with academic standards is ineffective, which inevitably leads to an increase in violations of academic ethics. The results of the study confirm the dominance of rational-pragmatic expediency in the scientific and pedagogical community today.



Pedagogical Psychology
General Education Teachers and Parents of Neurotypical Learners: A Comparative Analysis of Inclusive Dispositions
Аннотация
Introduction. The institutionalization of inclusive education defines a new context for considering issues of school-family cooperation, actualizing the tasks of building complementary interaction between teachers of general education organizations and parents of not only children with disabilities but also neurotypical learners. Since the optimization of school-parent relationships requires a transition to value-semantic interaction, the basis for interaction between teachers and parents in the context of inclusive education should be the subjective values and meanings that both parties associate with inclusion and which are embodied in their inclusive dispositions. However, the inclusive dispositions of teachers in general education organizations and parents of neurotypical schoolchildren have not yet been the subject of special comparative study. The aim of the research is to identify commonalities and specifics in the inclusive dispositions of these participants in inclusive educational relationships.
Materials and Methods. The study involved 759 general education teachers and 701 parents of neurotypical learners from seven federal districts of the Russian Federation. Both original and adapted diagnostic tools were employed, including: the authors’ method for assessing teachers’ inclusive self-identification, the Wilczenski Scale for measuring attitudes toward inclusive education, and a questionnaire on professional dispositions.
Results. Against the backdrop of identified reliable shifts in teachers’ assessments of their own inclusive dispositions and their prevalence among most other teachers, as well as in parents’ assessments of the inclusive dispositions of most teachers and ideal teachers, factor analysis reveals a similar latent structure of inclusive dispositions and attitudes towards inclusive education among teachers and parents of neurotypical learners. This similarity extends to the aspect of its comparative acceptability for children with different types of developmental disorders. Despite the differentiating influence of socio-demographic variables, there exists a core set of values and meanings that is common to teachers and parents of neurotypical learners as participants in inclusive educational relationships. It is precisely this zone of commonality in inclusive dispositions that defines the real value-semantic space of their interaction.
Discussion and Conclusion. The research materials may be of interest to administrators and educators in inclusive educational institutions, as well as to representatives of parent advocacy groups, for the purpose of optimizing school–family partnerships in the context of the institutionalization of inclusive education.



Professional Potential of Senior Teachers: Psychological and Pedagogical Aspect
Аннотация
Introduction. The relevance of this study is driven by the need to maintain the professional effectiveness of educators in the later stages of their teaching careers. At the same time, the very definition of “professional potential of senior teachers” and its psycho-pedagogical aspects remain understudied. The aim of this research is to identify the key characteristics of the professional potential of senior teachers and to determine criteria for its preservation in this age group of educators.
Materials and Methods. The study employed a method of analyzing scholarly literature on the topic, and a focus group method for discussing and refining theoretical conclusions. Eighty teachers from various regions of the Russian Federation participated in the focus groups, as well as 30 representatives from the academic and business communities during a series of national and international scientific conferences. These methods facilitated the identification of structural components and the systematization of the concepts of “personal potential”, “professional potential”, and “professional potential of senior teachers”, which are in morphogenetic dependence and are fundamental.
Results. It has been established that the professional potential of senior teachers is an integrative characteristic, the personal, social, and pedagogical aspects of which are consciously realized in professional activity and ensure its effectiveness. Evaluation criteria include subjective satisfaction with quality of life, sustained professional motivation, and readiness for life-long creativity. The results of the focus groups confirmed the alignment of the developed criteria with the current demands of the education system and their potential for objectively assessing the professional prospects of the target group under investigation.
Discussion and Conclusion. The results obtained have significant practical potential and can be used as a methodological basis for creating programs aimed at actualizing the professional potential of senior teachers, as well as applied in the practice of specialists in psychological services and centers for psychological, pedagogical, medical, and social assistance services in developing comprehensive support programs for this category of teaching staff.



Culture Shock Descriptions by Chinese Students Studying in Russia: Qualitative and Quantitative Analysis
Аннотация
Introduction. The growing number of students seeking education overseas influences economies, and the exploration of sociocultural adaptation among international students, with culture shock as an inherent element, is gaining prominence due to nations efforts to improve their competitiveness in attracting international learners. Nevertheless, the issues contributing to culture shock in non-Anglophone countries, including the experience of culture shock among Asian students, have not been adequately addressed in scholarly research. This study aims to examine culture shock experienced by Chinese students studying in Russia.
Materials and Methods. Quantitative and qualitative analysis of descriptions of culture shock made by 82 Chinese students at a Russian university. The results were processed using the R program, applying the chi-square test and Cramer’s V test to observe the independence of variables and their interrelationships. The binomial test, z-test, and analysis of variance (ANOVA) were also used to test statistical significance within and between groups.
Results. The culture shock intensity level varies depending on the time spent by a student in another culture. Descriptions by students who experienced the intense culture shock are distinguished by the simplicity and specificity of their problem statement. Descriptions of situations that caused low culture shock are formal, reflecting common opinions, stereotypes, and uncertainty in sociocultural adaptation.
Discussion and Conclusion. The study expands and substantiates the conception of culture shock as an integral part of sociocultural adaptation. Although the study refers to Chinese students, the results can be considered when studying the sociocultural adaptation of students of different nationalities.



Академическое письмо
Rhetoric of Promotion and Persuasion in Grant Proposal Abstracts
Аннотация
Introduction. Grant proposal abstracts represent a pivotal academic genre aimed at persuading experts in a specific field of research to fund the proposed projects. Being considered a “behind-the-scenes” genre, it has received little attention in academic discourse analysis and pedagogy. This study addresses this gap by analyzing rhetorical moves employed in grant proposal abstracts with a particular focus on their promotional and persuasive nature.
Materials and Methods. A corpus of 90 successfully funded linguistics grant proposals from the Russian Science Foundation was analyzed. The texts were derived from the official website of the fund. The analysis included a comprehensive procedure of extracting texts and conducting interpretative and quantitative analyses of the rhetorical moves using Matzler’s taxonomy. The corpus was chosen to provide insights into how persuasive and promotional language is used in a funding context.
Results. The analysis revealed a consistent pattern of moves indicative of persuasive language and strategic promotion. The study identified that the most frequent moves found in the corpus were Territory, Goals, and Benefits, which underline the importance of establishing a clear context, articulating research aims, and highlighting the significance and novelty of the proposed research. The most frequent move structure in the corpus was “Territory – Goal – Means – Benefits”, which indicates the conventional approach taken in the abstracts.
Discussion and Conclusion. Through a move analysis of grant proposal abstracts, the present study contributed to a deeper understanding of this persuasive and promotional academic genre. The analysis suggests a strong link between the successful use of specific rhetorical moves and securing funding, with variations in the types of moves identified in 90 abstracts. The findings highlight the persuasive and promotional nature of scientific communication and their implications for pedagogy. Explicit training in move analysis is recommended to improve researchers’ capacity to create convincing proposals.



The Use of Metadiscourse in Turkish EFL Learners’ L1 and L2 Argumentative Essays
Аннотация
Introduction. The use of metadiscourse facilitates writer-reader interaction and text coherence. While the incorporation of these rhetorical features in student argumentative essays has been frequently studied, comparative investigations of metadiscourse markers in L1 and L2 student essays have not received necessary attention. This study aims to reveal whether and how native Turkish university students employ metadiscoursal items in their L1 Turkish and L2 English argumentative essays written at a pre-intermediate level.
Materials and Methods. Drawing on Interpersonal Model of Metadiscourse, a comparative analysis was conducted on a corpus of 200 essays, comprising 100 in Turkish and 100 in English. A corpus-driven approach was employed to detect metadiscourse elements. Following identification of metadiscourse marker use, quantitative examination using SPSS tests was conducted to discern significant disparities between Turkish and English essays, complemented by qualitative analysis to elucidate how students employ metadiscourse markers to advance argumentative objectives.
Results. Both intra- and inter-linguistic analyses revealed the presence of all metadiscourse categories within the corpora, each serving specific functions. Notably, self-mentions emerged as the most frequently used category across all metadiscourse categories in both Turkish and English essays. The findings indicate that EFL learners employ metadiscourse markers as rhetorical tools to create argumentative, reader-friendly, and cohesive texts, thereby enriching our understanding of students’ expressive abilities in argumentative discourse.
Discussion and Conclusion. This study’s findings hold significant implications for language teaching, particularly in EFL contexts. By highlighting the effectiveness of metadiscourse markers as rhetorical tools, it suggests that explicit instruction in these markers can significantly enhance students’ writing proficiency and argumentative success. Language educators can incorporate activities focusing on identifying, analyzing, and strategically using various metadiscourse categories to empower learners to produce more sophisticated written communication.


