Vol 13, No 3 (2023)
- Year: 2023
- Published: 01.12.2023
- Articles: 10
- URL: https://bakhtiniada.ru/2410-0765/issue/view/23736
Full Issue
Articles
The raid of the Yaik Cossacks on the Khiva Khanate in 1603 in the description of military and civilian pre-revolutionary authors
Abstract
At the beginning of the 17th century, a detachment of Yaik Cossacks, led by ataman Nechai, raided the Khiva Khanate, plundering and ruining its capital – the city of Urgench. However, the raid ended tragically for the Cossacks – they were all killed by the troops of the Khan Arab-Mohammed, whose son, a few decades later, described this event in his book on the history of the Khanate. The disappearance of this ancient book with its preserved translations into various European languages, although they do not allow us to restore the contents of the protograph with absolute accuracy, but they show that the legends of the Ural Cossacks about the campaign of their ancestors led by Nechai to the Khiva Khanate reflect real events, that these are not myths and legends created by the imagination of the Cossacks. The works of all the authors mentioned in the article, despite the differences present in them, contain relatively small amounts of information about those events, since they, as a rule, cover a wide chronological framework, within which the raid of the Yaik Cossacks on the Khiva Khanate in 1603 is only a small episode. The article also analyzes the reasons for the differences in the coverage of this event by different authors.
10-30
Formation and development of the judicial system of the Russian Empire in the South Urals in the 1720s – 1750s
Abstract
The change in the political and administrative status of the Southern Urals, which had been part of the Ufa province since 1719, was accompanied by the renewal of the system of justice authorities, adapted to the socio-political and ethno-cultural conditions of the region. At the stage of its integration into Russia and the transformation from an external to an internal province of the empire, the plurality of jurisdictions that were sanctioned by the supreme power, pluralism in law enforcement corresponded to the diversity of the population of the region, contributing to the protection of corporate and private rights and interests, growth the authority of the state and the role of law in the regulation of social relations, and finally, the formation of a regional society.
31-45
Loan Operation in the Issues of Revisions of “Reliability of Capitals and Cashiers” of Mining Associations of State-Owned Mining Plants (second half of the 19th – early 20th centuries)
Abstract
This article discusses some fragmentary known aspects of the history of mining partnerships – the first domestic institution created in addition to state pension guarantees for retired "free rural residents" of state-owned mining plants in the Caucasus, the Urals, Karelia and Eastern Siberia.
When writing the article, materials from two Russian archives and, mainly, pre-revolutionary author's publications in the Mining Journal, the official publication of the Mining Scientific Committee, were used.
The problematic characteristics of loan transactions are analyzed by the content of the identified facts of "neglect" and "damages" investigated during inspections of the activities of the Kusinsky, Zlatoust and Satka partnerships in 1881, 1877–1884 and 1911–1913, respectively. The indicators of financial and material "sustainability" of the system of partnerships as new formations of the post-reform era are given.
46-59
Smallpox vaccination in the Orenburg province
Abstract
Author studies the history of smallpox vaccination in the Orenburg province of the second half of the 19th – early 20th centuries. Vaccination is considered against the background of the incidence of smallpox. The development of Immunization on this eastern outskirts was characterized by positive (albeit unstable) dynamics and slower pace than in European Russia. The reasons for this situation were covered in organizational troubles and lay in the presence of anti-vaxxer groups (non-russians («inorodcy»), Cossacks, Old Believers («staroobrjadcy»), migrants). The First World War negatively affected the results of immunization and the development of smallpox epidemics in the region.
60-77
Formation of an entrepreneurial economy in animal husbandry (Southern Urals, mid-19th – early 20th centuries)
Abstract
After agriculture, the second main branch of farming in the Southern Urals was animal husbandry, especially for semi-nomadic and nomadic peoples. Since the 19th century an entrepreneurial, market economy is being formed, primarily in horse breeding and sheep breeding. However, due to the short duration of the livestock trade, identifying the actors in the livestock market remains a challenge for historians. The article uses new methods of searching and analyzing sources. In addition to the published data on the noble, landowner economy, where there is information about the number of livestock, direct and indirect information about large-scale, market livestock raising in the Bashkir-Meshcheryak army, as well as information from veterinary point doctors who controlled the arrival of cattle from other regions, was involved. The widest possible coverage of sources made it possible to establish that already from the first half of the 19th century. in the southern Urals there was trade horse breeding and sheep breeding. A large number of horses were sold at the Menzelinsky fair; individual herds were even brought to Nizhny Novgorod. Horse breeding for sale existed among the Turkic peoples (Bashkirs and Tatars), it was represented by both large stud farms and small businesses in the countryside. he development of market relations in the 19th – early 20th centuries in the Southern Urals was observed in animal husbandry, which was stimulated by the ancient traditions of the semi-nomadic Bashkirs.
78-96
1916 in Ufa: Tatar view
Abstract
The article analyzes the life of the Tatar intelligentsia in Ufa in 1916 through the prism of ego-documents and in the context of the World War I. The main sources are the works of Shaikhzada Babich, Galiasgar Gafurov-Chygtai, Saifi Kudash and Zarif Bashiri. 1916 was a jubilee year for Tatar culture – 10 years since the founding of the Tatar theater, the establishment of newspapers, the opening of a madrasah. For Ufa, such iconic dominants were the Galia madrasah, the Tormysh newspaper, and the Nur troupe. Particular attention is paid to the conflict around the Galia madrasah, the relationship between Shaikhzad Babich and Sagit Suncheley, as well as the daily life of the military period. The author concluded that the conflicts of this period were continued in revolutionary times. Some pre-revolutionary episodes were mythologized thanks to memoirs of a later nature.
97-117
The “Constitution” of Idel-Ural as the foundation of multinational statehood
Abstract
The question of the national autonomy of the Turko-Tatar peoples of Russia has been in the air for quite a long time. At the First All-Russian Muslim Congress, held in Moscow in May 1917, while discussing the question of the state structure of Russia, delegates split into two camps – Unitarians and federalists. The latter soon won the victory, immediately starting to draw up a project of national-territorial autonomy. One of these projects was the “Idel-Ural State”. At present, a considerable array of scientific research has been accumulated on the process of preparing and proclaiming the project of the State of Idel-Ural as a multinational state. However, among these studies there are no works that would cover the legal component of this project.
As a result of a long meeting of the National Assembly of Turko-Tatar Muslims in January 1918, a number of resolutions came into being, which generally established the framework for the subsequent constitutionalization of law and order in the State of Idel-Ural. The combination of these resolutions can be given the conditional name “Constitution” of Idel-Ural. It fixed the path of development of constitutionalism, and guaranteed the fundamental principles of building statehood: national equality, federalism, democracy, political and ideological pluralism. The “Constitution” of Idel-Ural played a particularly important role in the practice of state building of the Tatar people. This work aims to provide a general analysis of the provisions of this legal document, and thereby reveal the hidden areas of the state-legal history of the Tatars.
118-135
Publication of the source
“Tatar ... to pay a salary yasak against the Bashkirs by the fox for a year”. On the influence of the state fiscal policy on the formation of social groups of the Ufa district population at the end of the 17th century
Abstract
The publication presents documents from the fund “Ufa Prikaznaya Izba” of the Russian State Archive of Ancient Acts, which help to assess the process of formation of social groups of the yasak population of Ufa district in the last third of the 17th century and the influence of the state's fiscal policy on this process. The documents shed light on the role of the state in the stratification of rural residents, as well as the mechanisms for integrating migrants from the Pre-Kama region into the established social structure of the local society.
136-160
New books, reviews
Book review: Lyubimov A.G., Novozhilova L.A. At the breaking: from the history of the Orenburg Cossacks: articles, essays (Chelyabinsk, 2023)
Abstract
This review is an analysis of a new collection of articles and essays on the history of the Orenburg Cossack army (OCA), covering mainly the period from 1914 to the 1930s. The work is replete with rich factual material, collected for the most part in the archives. Here the reader discovers information about the missing, wounded, killed Cossacks during the First World War (1914–1918) and the Civil War (1917– 1922). The authors focus their attention on the events that took place on the territory of the modern Chelyabinsk region. When publishing memoirs about N.D. Kashirin provides comments and brief information about the contemporaries of the events.
161-166
Scientific life
The History of medieval Bashkirs in the ethnogenetic discourse of R.G. Kuzeev
Abstract
The ethnogenetic concept of R.G. Kuzeev, according to which the Belebeevo-Bugulma upland from the end of the 1st millennium A.D. is the territory of the formation of the Bashkir people, has established itself in historiography, and for several decades various researchers and publicists rely on it in their research. However, its main provisions are not verified. Sources of the 10th–15th centuries do not connect medieval Bashkirs (“bashgart”, “baskart”, “paskatir”) with the territory of the Belebeevo-Bugulma upland, and the sources of the 16th century localize the Bashkirs (“Bashkird”, “Bashkirs”) in the Perm Kama region. The composition and localization of the ethno-tribal divisions of the medieval Bashkirs were established by R.G. Kuzeev on the basis of data from sources of the 18th–19th centuries. But this extrapolation was carried out without taking into account the significant ethno-social changes that occurred in the 17th–18th centuries. Therefore, it is obvious that the concept of R.G. Kuzeev does not stand up to scientific criticism, and the ideas about the ethnogenesis of the medieval Bashkirs that have developed on its basis need to be substantially corrected.
167-178

