The pragmatic concept of species in vascular plants
- Authors: Onipchenko V.G.1, Zernov A.S.1
-
Affiliations:
- Lomonosov Moscow State University, Faculty of Biology
- Issue: Vol 86, No 3 (2025)
- Pages: 177-182
- Section: (Indexed in “Current Contents”)
- URL: https://bakhtiniada.ru/0044-4596/article/view/306113
- DOI: https://doi.org/10.31857/S0044459625030027
- EDN: https://elibrary.ru/bikahf
- ID: 306113
Cite item
Abstract
The objective uncertainty of the taxonomic category “species” in vascular plants, associated with the lack of clear thresholds in the degree of feature divergence between populations and the continuity of evolution, allows plant taxonomists to arbitrarily divide populations into “species”. In the minds of many researchers, ideas about the special meaning (sacredness) of the species category and the objective existence of species persist. All this negatively affects both the study of the processes of biodiversity formation and the use of the species category in other fields of fundamental science and applied research. The authors consider convenience for identification and usefulness to be the most important parameters in the separation of species. So, the main criteria to separate species should be usefulness as for botanists and for researches in other sciences. According to our expert estimates, at least 80% of the world’s plant taxonomists use this parameter but, possibly, sometimes unconsciously. The possibility and applicability of other criteria, including reproductive isolation and age of taxa, is discussed.
About the authors
V. G. Onipchenko
Lomonosov Moscow State University, Faculty of Biology
Email: vonipchenko@mail.ru
Leninskie gory, 1, Moscow, 119234 Russia
A. S. Zernov
Lomonosov Moscow State University, Faculty of Biology
Author for correspondence.
Email: vonipchenko@mail.ru
Leninskie gory, 1, Moscow, 119234 Russia
References
- Грант В., 1984. Видообразование у растений. М.: Мир. 528 с.
- Дарвин Ч., 1937. Происхождение видов. М.; Л.: ОГИЗ-СЕЛЬХОЗГИЗ. 608 с.
- Еленевский А.Г., 1969. Перспективы применения политипической концепции вида в систематике растений // Журн. общ. биологии. Т. 30. № 2. С. 174–185.
- Еленевский А.Г., 1980. О внутривидовой изменчивости и таксономии // Бюл. МОИП. Отд. биол. Т. 85. Вып. 6. С. 87–99.
- Забияко А.П., 2010. Сакральное // Новая философская энциклопедия: в 4 т. / Институт философии РАН. Т. 3. М.: Мысль. С. 482–483.
- Камелин Р.В., 2004. Лекции по систематике растений. Барнаул: Азбука. 226 с.
- Комаров В.Л., 1940. Учение о виде у растений. М.; Л.: Изд-во АН СССР. 212 с.
- Линней К., 1989. Философия ботаники. М.: Наука. 456 с.
- Луферов А.Н., 2012. Anemone // Конспект флоры Кавказа. Т. 3. Ч. 2. СПб.; М.: Т-во науч. изд. КМК. С. 88–90.
- Любищев А.А., 1982. Проблемы формы систематики и эволюции организмов. М.: Наука. 279 с.
- Майр Э., 1968. Зоологический вид и эволюция. М.: Мир. 598 с.
- Майр Э., 1971. Принципы зоологической систематики. М.: Мир. 456 с.
- Майр Э., 1974. Популяции, виды и эволюция. М.: Мир. 460 с.
- Мельников Д.Г., 2013. Новые таксоны в роде Clinopodium L. (Lamiaceae) // Новости сист. высш. раст. Т. 44. С. 174–205. https://doi.org/10.31111/novitates/2013.44.174
- Скворцов А.К., 1967. Основные этапы развития представлений о виде // Бюлл. МОИП. Отд. биол. Т. 72. № 5. С. 11–27.
- Юзепчук С.В., 1958. Комаровская концепция вида, ее историческое развитие и отражение во “Флоре СССР” // Проблемы вида в ботанике / Под ред. Баранова П.А. и др. М.; Л.: Изд-во АН СССР. С. 130–204.
- Ackerfield J., 2015. Flora of Colorado. Fort Worth: Botanical Research Inst. of Texas. 818 p.
- Bock J.H., Jolls C.L., Lewis A.C., 1995. The effects of grazing on alpine vegetation: A comparison of the Central Caucasus, Republic of Georgia, with the Colorado Rocky Mountains, USA // Arctic Alpine Res. V. 27. № 2. P. 130–136.
- Brooks T.M., Helgen K.M., 2010. A standard for species // Nature. V. 467. Р. 540–541.
- Bryant J.P., Joly K., Chapin F.S. III, DeAngelis D.L., Kielland K., 2014. Can antibrowsing defense regulate the spread of woody vegetation in arctic tundra? // Ecography. V. 37. № 3. Р. 204–211.
- Davis P.H., 1965–1980. Flora of Turkey and the East Aegean Islands. V. 1–10. Edinburg: Edinburg Univ. Press.
- Dransfield J., Uhl N.W., Asmussen C.B., Baker W.J., Harley M.M., Lewis C.E., 2008. Genera Palmarum – The Evolution and Classification of the Palms. Kew: Royal Botanic Gardens. 744 p.
- Hou Y., Bjora C.S., Ikeda H., Brochmann C., Popp M., 2016. From the north into the Himalayan-Hengduan Mountains: Fossil-calibrated phylogenetic and biogeographical inference in the arctic-alpine genus Diapensia (Diapensiaceae) // J. Biogeogr. V. 43. № 8. Р. 1502–1513.
- Ithnin M., Vu W.T., Marjuni M. et al., 2024. Elaeis species specific SNPs allow authentication of natural hybrids in a wild E. oleifera germplasm collection // Biocatal. Agric. Biotechnol. V. 60. Art. 103304.
- Kattge J., Bonisch G., Diaz S., Lavorel S., Prentice I.C. et al., 2020. TRY plant trait database – enhanced coverage and open access // Global Change Biol. V. 26. № 1. Р. 119–188.
- Kattge J., Diaz S., Lavorel S., Prentice I.C., Leadley P. et al., 2011. TRY – a global database of plant traits // Global Change Biol. V. 17. № 9. Р. 2905–2935.
- Lesica P., 2012. Manual of Montana Vascular Plants. Fort Worth: Botanical Research Inst. of Texas. 772 p.
- Levin D.A., Scarpino S.V., 2017. On the young age of intraspecific herbaceous taxa // New Phytol. V. 213. № 3. Р. 1513–1520.
- Linnaeus K., 1753. Species Plantarum. Holmiae: L. Salvius. 1200 p.
- Lock J.M., 1996. Editor’s preface // Legumes of Northern Eurasia. A Checklist / Eds Yakovlev G.P., Sytin A.K., Roskov Yu.R. Kew: Royal Botanic Gardens. 724 p.
- Lv Y., Gao Y., Cui Y., Wang Y., Fan Z., et al., 2022. Interfamily wide hybridization between daylily (Hemerocallis, Xanthorrhoeaceae) and lycoris (Lycoris, Amaryllidaceae) // Plant Breeding. V. 141. № 6. Р. 820–827.
- Mayr E., 1970. Population, Species, and Evolution. Cambridge: Belknap Press of Harvard Univ. Press. 453 p.
- Ollerton J., Winfree R., Tarrant S., 2011. How many flowering plants are pollinated by animals? // Oikos. V. 120. № 3. Р. 321–326.
- Poincare H., 1904. La science et l’hypothese. Paris: Flammarion. 284 p.
- Toll K., 2023. An evolutionary framework for understanding habitat partitioning in plants // Am. J. Bot. V. 110. № 1. Art. e16119.
- Willdenow K.L., 1799. Caroli a Linne Species Plantarum exhibentes plantas rite cognitas ad genera relatas. T. 2. Рs 2. Berolini: Impensis G.C. Nauk. 511 р.
Supplementary files
