The light and shadows of Ukrainophilia: the state policy of ukrainization and indigenization in the USSR in the 1920s
- 作者: Akzhigitov R.R.1
-
隶属关系:
- Penza State University
- 期: 编号 1 (2025)
- 页面: 110-123
- 栏目: LAW
- URL: https://bakhtiniada.ru/2072-3016/article/view/297098
- DOI: https://doi.org/10.21685/2072-3016-2025-1-9
- ID: 297098
如何引用文章
全文:
详细
Background. The article is devoted to the strengthening of Ukrainian nationalism in the first years of the USSR in connection with the state policy of Ukrainization and in-digenization, which allows us to understand the origins of the modern version of the con-cept of Ukrainophile exclusivity. The author sets the task of analyzing the objective picture of the mixing of ethnic groups in Ukraine and the subjective efforts of the Ukrainian eth-nocracy to transition to ethnic dominance. The motives of the federal center for sanctioning the implementation of the policy of Ukrainization and indigenization are revealed. Materials and methods. A whole series of publications on the ethnolinguistic situation in Ukraine in the second half of the 19th century – 1920s, statistical and party sources (stenographic reports of the 12th Congress of the RCP(b) and the 4th meeting of the Central Committee of the RCP(b) are used. The author uses methods of analysis and synthesis, comparison, and publishes important tabular material. Results. The absence of Ukraine as a single territorial-administrative massif spurred the Ukrainophile intelligentsia, in the conditions of revolu-tionary destabilization of 1917, to ideological and territorial expansion in the person of the Kyiv Central Rada. However, during the Civil War, supporters of the petty-bourgeois na-tionalist idea did not receive priority support – Ukraine nevertheless became Soviet. Never-theless, the Bolsheviks, fearing Ukrainophilia, made unjustified concessions to the latter. They were expressed in the forced integration of Novorossiya into Ukraine, and later in the policy of linguistic Ukrainization of languages. But very soon the formal equality of lan-guages was transformed into the provision of personnel and material preferences to the bearers of the idea of Ukrainianism. It was defended in the party and bureaucratic elite by H.G. Rakovsky, N.A. Skrypnik, G.F. Grinʼko, A.Ya. Shumsky, V.P. Zatonsky, V.Ya. Chu-bar. Initially, the course towards Ukrainianization was actually sabotaged at the bottom, but with the arrival of the tough Stalinist appointee L.M. Kaganovich, a turning point occurred. At the same time, the nationalistic outrages in which individual representatives of the crea-tive intelligentsia, such as M. Khvylovy, were noticed, prompted the central government to become wary and the campaign gradually began to wind down. Conclusions. The policy of Ukrainization should be considered as part of the course of indigenization, which provided for worldwide assistance in the socio-cultural development of indigenous ethnic groups. In the context of Ukraine, the passion for this policy, along with its positive cultural component, was fraught with many dangers due to the size and strategic importance of the republic, its ethnic heterogeneity (primarily the presence of Russian-speaking Novorossi-ya), and the aggressiveness of Ukrainian chauvinism, which dreamed of subjugating Rus-sian-speaking cities. Finally, the situation was complicated by the protracted flirtation with the nationalists on the part of the center, which was largely abandoned only in the early 1930s.
作者简介
Rinat Akzhigitov
Penza State University
编辑信件的主要联系方式.
Email: makwwwin@yandex.ru
Postgraduate student
(40 Krasnaya street, Penza, Russia)参考
- Gulyakov A.D., Salomatin A.Yu. Kak nashe gosudarstvo stalo federativnym? (Analiz otechestvennogo istoriko-gosudarstvennogo opyta): monografiya = How did our state become federal? (Analysis of domestic historical and state experience): monograph. Penza: Izd-vo PGU, 2019:150. (In Russ.)
- Yaroshevich A. Little Russia according to the 1897. Kievskaya starina = Kyiv antiquity. Kiev: Tip. Imperatorskago un-ta sv. Vladimira Akts. obshch. N.T. Korchak-Novitskago, 1905:13. (In Russ.)
- Bruk I., Kabuzan V.M. The number and distribution of the Ukrainian ethnic group in the 17th – early 20th centuries. Sovetskaya etnografiya = Soviet ethnography. 1981;(5):15–31. (In Russ.)
- Boyko Ya.V. Zaselenie Yuzhnoy Ukrainy. Formirovanie etnicheskogo sostava naseleni-ya kraya: russkie i ukraintsy (konets XVIII – nachalo XXI v.): etnostatisticheskiy ocherk Vyp. 1 = Settlement of Southern Ukraine. Formation of the ethnic composition of the re-gion’s population: Russians and Ukrainians (late 18th – early 21st century): ethnostatis-tical essay. Issue 1. Cherkassy: Vertikal', 2007:48. (In Russ.)
- Mozgovoy S.G. Internal and external aspects of Ukrainian nationalism in 1863–1914. Universum: Obshchestvennye nauki = Universum: social sciences. 2016;(1-4). (In Russ.). Available at: https://cyberleninka.ru/article/n/vnutrennyaya-i-vneshnyaya-storony-ukrainskogo-natsionaliz-ma-v-1863-1914-gg/viewer
- Khripachenko T.I. Failed compromise: russian liberals and projects of Polish and Ukrainian autonomy in the russian empire on the eve of World War I. Peterburgskie slavyanskie i balkanskie issledovaniya = Petersburg Slavic and Balkan Studies. 2015;(1). (In Russ.). Available at: https://cyberleninka.ru/article/n/neudavshiysya-kompromiss-rossiyskie-liberaly-i-proekty-polskoy-i-ukrainskoy-avtonomii-v-rossiys-koy-imperii-nakanune-pervoy-miro-voy-voyny/viewer
- Krutikov A. “Let us live in peace”. Ukrainian Constituent Assembly 1917–1918. Per-spektiva. Elektronnyy zhurnal = Perspective. Electronic journal. 2020;4 Aug. (In Russ.). Available at: https://www.perspektivy.info/history/dajte_spokojno_pozhit_ ukrainskoje_uchreditelnoje_sobranije_1917__1918_gg_2020-08-04.htm
- Tolochko P.P., Oleynikov A.A., Simonenko R.G. Istoriya Ukrainy VI–XXI vv. 2-e izd., ispr. i dop. = History f Ukraine of the 6th – 21st centuries. The 2nd editiоn, revised and supplemented. Kiev; Moscow: Kievskaya Rus': Kuchkovo pole, 2018:472. (In Russ.)
- Mikhaylov I.V. “Ukrainian revolution” or revolution in Ukraine? Vestnik MGIMO-Universiteta = Bulletin of MGIMO-University. 2010;(1):65–75. (In Russ.)
- Lyuksemburg R. Manuscript on the Russian Revolution. O sotsializme i russkoy revoly-utsii. Izbrannye stat'i, rechi, pis'ma = On socialism and the Russian Revolution. Selected articles, speeches, letters. Moscow: Politizdat, 1991. (In Russ.). Available at: https:// document.wikireading.ru/hb5YSKnCfW
- Durdenivskiy V.N. Ravnopravie yazykov v Sovetskom stroe = Equality of languages in the Soviet system. Moscow: [b. i.], 1927:243. (In Russ.)
- Tayny natsional'noy politiki TsK RKP: chetvertoe soveshchanie TsK RKP s otvetstvennymi rabotnikami natsional'nykh respublik i oblastey v g. Moskve 9–12 iyunya 1923 g.: stenogr. otchet. Rossiyskiy mezhdunarodnyy fond kul'tury; vstup. st. B.F. Sul-tanbekova = Secrets of the national policy of the Central Committee of the RCP: the fourth meeting of the Central Committee of the RCP with responsible workers of the national republics and regions in Moscow on June 9–12, 1923: verbatim report. Moscow: Insan, 1992:293. (In Russ.)
- Medvedev A. Podlinnaya istoriya russkogo i ukrainskogo naroda = The true history of the Russian and Ukrainian people. Moscow: Eksmo, 2015:506. (In Russ.)
- Krutikov A. “Until Our Power Gains Strength”. The Bolsheviks and the Ukrainian national question in 1917–1923. Perspektivy. Elektronnyy zhurnal = Prospects. Electronic journal. 2019;18 Jul. (In Russ.). Available at: https://www.perspektivy.info/history/ poka_nasha_vlast_ne_okrepnet_bolsheviki_i_ukrainskij_nacionalnyj_vopros_v_1917__1923_gg_2019-07-18.htm
- Silnitskiy F. Natsional'naya politika KPSS (1917–1922 gg.). 3-e izd. = National policy of the CPSU (1917–1922). The 3rd edition. Vashington: Problemy Vost. Evropy, 1990:312. (In Russ.)
- Dvenadtsatyy s"ezd Rossiyskoy kommunisticheskoy partii (bol'shevikov). 17–25 aprelya 1923 g.: stenogr. otchet = Twelfth Congress of the Russian Communist Party (Bolsheviks). April 17–25, 1923: verbatim report. Moscow: Politizdat, 1968:903. (In Russ.)
- Vdovin A.I. SSSR. Istoriya velikoy derzhavy. 1922–1991 = USSR. History of a Great Power. 1922–1991. Moscow: Prospekt, 2018:767. (In Russ.)
- Borisenok E.Yu. Fenomen sovetskoy ukrainizatsii 1920–1930-e gg. = The phenomenon of Soviet Ukrainization in the 1920–1930ss. Moscow: Evropa, 2006:256. (In Russ.)
- Marchukov A.V. Novorossiya. Formirovanie natsional'nykh identichnostey (XVIII–XX vv.) = Novorossiya. Formation of National Identities (18th – 20th centuries). Moscow: Kuchkovo pole, 2018:510. (In Russ.)
- Martin T. Imperiya «polozhitel'noy deyatel'nosti». Natsii i natsional'nosti v SSSR, 1923–1939 = The empire of “positive activity”. Nations and nationalities in the USSR, 1923–1939. Transl. from English by O.R. Shchelokova. Moscow: ROSSPEN: Pre-zidentskiy tsentr B.N. El'tsina, 2011:662. (In Russ.)
补充文件
